In today’s headlines with Chereè Kinnear the most burgled neighbourhoods revealed, debate over speed limit increases and cardiologists warn of a heart services crisis.
Each year around 40,000 New Zealanders are disconnected from the power supply for non-payment, according to Consumer NZ. They are surviving winter in cold, dark homes without access to a warm shower or a homecooked meal – some for months. Meanwhile, the main players in the power business are making huge profits – including charging hundreds for reconnections, often done by the touch of a button. In the first part of a series about power, we speak to those going without.
At least twice a week, the pre-paid power meter in Maddy Walker’s Hamilton home glows red and the scramble is on to scrape together money to top up.
Sometimes a $20 loan from Maddy’s sister gets them through – other weeks, the power is disconnected and the family of four are on the cold and soul-destroying countdown until payday.
“We’ve had times recently where we’ve gone to the pools for a shower, we have a chilly bin for food and I cook on the BBQ,” Maddy, not her real name, said.
“Even when I have topped up, we try to go without the heater because it drains the meter so quickly.”
Maddy signed up to Mercury Energy’s Glo-bug pre-paid system when she was disconnected from her previous supplier after getting behind on payments and racking up a $700 bill a few years ago.
“I had so many bills coming in and I couldn’t keep up. I got notices they were going to disconnect me but I couldn’t afford it I thought they would let me pay it off,” she said.
“When it was disconnected I was so embarrassed. One of my boys had friends over and there was no power. I was ashamed and pretended there was a power cut.”
Maddy and Jenna’s experiences with energy hardship are not uncommon according to those who run New Zealand’s City Missions.
In the last two weeks alone, more than six desperate households have called the Auckland City Mission asking for food and assistance, solely because of a high power bill.
Ellen Lear from the Mission said this included a solo mum who had not eaten for three days because her whole benefit of $382 went on a power bill to avoid disconnection.
Carla Ceppi from Wellington City Mission had assisted a family with two children who had lived without electricity for four months.
“They had cold showers every now and again and the children ate meals at school and just had snacks at home.”
“The family were very ashamed; they took four months to come to us,” Ceppi said.
Ceppi said it was unacceptable for families to go without an essential service when power companies profited through disconnection and reconnection charges.
“We don’t think it’s fair that people who already can’t afford the actual bill have to pay for disconnection, arrears, and the $200 on top for reconnection.”
So what is energy hardship?
The Ministry of Business, Innovation, and Employment (MBIE) defines energy hardship as households who have either struggled to pay energy bills in the past year, not heated their home adequately, put up with feeling cold to keep costs down and lived with dampness.
Dr Kimberley O’Sullivan from Otago University added energy hardship was “tricky to measure” and said as well as not being able to maintain their homes at a healthy temperature, there were also those going into debt or rationing other necessities.
For those living it, it could be taking the family to the local pools for a shower because there’s no hot water, eating a cold meal by torch or candlelight, cooking outside on the BBQ or skipping meals to pay the power bill.
Whatever the measure it’s clear people are making dangerous and heartbreaking choices in the coldest months to keep the power or to get reconnected.
This comes as Consumer NZ reports the financial records of the ‘big four’ power companies - Meridian, Contact, Genesis and Mercury – had combined earnings of $2.7 billion over the last year – about $7.4 million a day.
In 2023 that meant a combined net profit after tax of $520m.
Disconnection means a bad credit score, so the only option for those cut off often is the more expensive prepaid power.
According to Paul Fuge at Consumer NZ prepay customers are paying around 13% more despite being less able to afford it.
Kiwi children are going to bed cold with an estimated 50 households a night are going without power according to Consumer NZ.
Recent research by the consumer watchdog also revealed around 18% of people had experienced financial difficulty paying their bills and 13% had to borrow from family and friends to pay a bill.
Around 11% of people said their home was not warm enough because they couldn’t afford the extra money to heat their home.
As an essential service, Consumer NZ said the electricity connection should never be removed because of non-payment.
“Ongoing access to safe, reliable, and affordable electricity is fundamental to our health and wellbeing, and our ability to function in a modern society,” Fuge said.
Heartbreaking choices
Advocates for those struggling tell of solo mums only using power when their children are home, families turning the hot water cylinder off for days, using a BBQ to cook dinner and not heating the home.
Disconnection and reconnection fees of around $27 to $300 are an added hit for already financially stressed families.
Some say they have no choice but to stay disconnected.
Those on pre-pay systems such as Glo-Bug tell of the anxiety that comes when the “device glows amber or red” and they know disconnection is imminent unless they top up.
Some go for days, weeks and even months without power because they don’t have $10 to make the minimum payment.
Energy hardship expert Kimberly O’Sullivan from the University of Otago has made it her life’s work to research and find solutions for those struggling to keep the lights on.
Families often sleep together for warmth in one room to avoid heating the whole house. Photo / Stephen Parker
O’Sullivan has been into “freezing and unheated homes” to speak with people living without power.
She tells of families who have lived without power for months.
No heating, no hot showers, no light at the touch of a switch. Just cold, unhappy hardship.
“That was one of the more severe cases but there are others out there that we don’t hear about,” O’Sullivan said.
“One family had been disconnected and then went without power for four months because they were unable to reconnect.”
O’Sullivan said it was unacceptable that thousands of New Zealand households were living without the basic right of power.
She had walked up paths “with frost on the grass” and sat in “freezing unheated homes” to hear heartbreaking stories from people who were struggling to keep the lights on.
Some will go without other essentials to “keep the light on” because of the shame they feel when the power is cut.
“They don’t want the neighbours to notice the power has been off for days on end so they go without to pay the power bill.”
“There are parents who will skip a meal and families who will turn off the hot water cylinder for days so they can afford the bill.”
O’Sullivan said it was unacceptable that families were living without power but even more heartbreaking was those dying without it.
Living and dying without power
In 2007, Māngere woman Folole Muliaga died hours after a Mercury Energy contractor cut the power to the home because of an unpaid bill.
Muliaga was using an oxygen machine and the coroner ruled the lack of electricity contributed to her death.
“For me that kicked things off, because after that I was speaking to kaumātua and they were using oxygen machines and they were really worried,” she said.
Family members grieve at the casket of Folole Muliaga, who died after electricity was cut off to their home because the bill was not paid. Photo / Glenn Jeffrey
Despite policy changes that came about after Muliaga’s death, O’Sullivan said there were numerous deaths where power poverty was a hidden factor.
“We don’t see it reported but if you look carefully there are people who are dying because of the way they are heating their house or what they are doing to cope without power.”
This included deaths resulting from patio heaters used inside, candles used for light and children dying from illnesses caused by living in a damp and cold home.
Too many are going cold
Data from the 2023 Energy Hardship Expert Panel’s final report revealed 110,000 households could not afford to keep their home adequately warm.
But that figure is grossly underestimated according to others working in the field.
O’Sullivan, the energy hardship expert from the University of Otago, said that figure was drawn from people who said they could not heat their home “a lot” of the time.
“Based on current research we are undertaking we’re finding between 16-30% of homes are affected, depending on the measure used,” she said.
“This is much higher than the most recent report by MBIE finding that 110,000 households or 5.8% of homes are unable to keep warm.”
The report also revealed in 2017 alone living in a damp or mouldy house in New Zealand led to 6,276 hospitalisations and represented a cost of $36m.
Prominent lawyer Olinda Woodroffe, who represented the Muliaga family, said it was a sad indictment that 17 years after Folole Muliaga’s death there were still average New Zealand households rationing or living without power.
“We have a duty to ensure all people in the community have access to power, particularly those who are elderly, unwell and families,” Woodroffe said.
“We know it’s good for businesses to make a profit but with essential services such as electricity, the focus should be wellbeing people’s health needs to be protected irrespective of their income.”
