Meanwhile, in Christchurch, defending Chatham Cup champions Cashmere Technical were almost knocked out by Western AFC in the first round.
Western were leading 2-1 in second-half injury time but Cashmere equalised to force the game into extra time. Cashmere then added two goals in extra time to win the match 4-2.
In the WaiBOP Premiership, Rotorua United had a disappointing 2-0 loss to Katikati away.
United would have been hopeful of collecting some much-needed competition points from the match, but Dane Stollery struck twice for Katikati, which was enough to determine the result.
League leaders Cambridge notched up another win with a 2-0 victory over Tauranga Boys' College.
- Results on Saturday:
WaiBOP Premiership: Papamoa 3 Tauranga Old Blues 1, Cambridge 2 Tauranga Boys' College 0, Katikati 2 Rotorua United 0.
WaiBOP Championship: Tokoroa 1 Claudelands Rovers 4, Te Awamutu 0 West Hamilton 6, Tauranga Old Blues 3 Ngongotaha 5.
Bay of Plenty teams in the Chatham Cup: Bucklands Beach 2 Ngongotaha 5, Albany United 5 Kawerau Sports 2, Glen Eden United 2 Tauranga City United 6, Te Puke United 1 Onehunga-Mangere 4, Otumoetai FC 2 Hibiscus Coast 3 aet.