Papakura fought back and Charlie Heather scored in the 85th minute before Wild scored his second to tie the game.
Ngongotaha coach Shane Davis was disappointed about the way his side threw away the lead, but said the result was probably a fair reflection of the game.
"I thought we had it in the bag, but it wasn't to be. A couple of errors cost us and resulted in a draw.
"We played really well to go up 3-1 and scored some quality goals, we just didn't shut up shop," Davis said.
The man of the match for Ngongotaha was goalkeeper James Towers who saved a penalty.
The result sees Ngongotaha hold onto sixth place and they still have a game in hand over most teams above them.
"We've got four games left and we just need to keep picking up points and try and finish in the top four," he said.