``He ran outside and hit her in the head with it,'' Mrs Graham said. ``Afterwards he then went back inside . . . he left her, literally, lying in a pool of blood.'' She said his response was ``definitely'' not reasonable given the circumstances.
Whatarau's defence lawyer Scott Jefferson asked the woman if she had picked on Whatarau at the party earlier that night. He also asked her if she had arrived home in a ``jealous rage'', and suggested she had tried to run at him with a stick.
Mr Jefferson said a neighbour's statement described Whatarau as retreating away from her. Her account of the night was ``completely'' at odds with the neighbour's, he said.
The trial is expected to continue tomorrow.