Alan Taylor was equally blunt.
"We don't need an online poll. The community will be split. I think we should just make a decision."
The Prime Minister wants to know New Zealanders' opinions on fireworks, council policy analyst Justin Walters said, but it won't be a high priority for Government unless people say so.
Several councillors felt it would be good to get the opinion of residents - but not at the potentially $30,000 cost of a non-binding poll posted out with election papers.
There are already two questions going out to voters, Councillor Josh Chandulal-MacKay said. They are important questions about democracy - one of them is whether to use the STV system for voting.
Fireworks would dilute the importance of those two questions, he said.
He and most of the others supported council's policy team doing an online poll, despite the fact it will not be as "scientific" as a voter version and could go into the Facebook "echo chamber".
Once public views are known the matter could be put forward to LGNZ as a remit - the option favoured by both Fallen and committee chairwoman Kate Joblin.