But the home team picked themselves up and were desperately unlucky not to score several times. The crowd got behind them as they continued to take the game to Mangere but with two minutes left the visitors, against the run of play, made it 2-0 and that was how it ended.
"We played well and were the best team for eighty-six of the ninety minutes," Whakatane Coach Mike Ward said.
"It's disappointing but the boys can hold their heads high."
Otumoetai lost 3-0 to Waitemata and it was also a 3-0 loss for Waikato Unicol against Oratia meaning that all four WaiBop Federation League sides were eliminated.
In the one federation league game, Tauranga Boys' College upset AFC Fury 1-0.