Progress Ngongotaha chairwoman Lynn Benfell previously said the Railway Park had offered space for the sculpture while it was being fixed, and local artist Paul Nicolai had contacted the original artist in the hope he would help with its restoration.
Estimates suggest it could cost more than $15,000 to repair.
Mrs Henderson said the sculpture was "ugly".
"We got lots of people saying the same thing, that's a lot of people too and our Maori community were up in arms - they certainly don't want it here."
Mrs Henderson said she had not heard anything more from Progress Ngongotaha and their plans for the sculpture.
"But we will make sure it doesn't get put up here in Ngongotaha. It was never popular when it was in town and we don't want that old rubbish here," she said.
It is still not known what Progress Ngongotaha want to do with the sculpture, if anything.
Mrs Benfell did not respond to requests from the Rotorua Daily Post for further information or comment.