Mr Tolley joined Wild Bean Cafe four years ago and said he enjoyed the training and commitment to excellence that was required when becoming a Wild Bean Cafe barista.
"I love the interaction with customers and having them watch as I make a mean coffee."
Wild Bean Cafe general manager Frank van Hattum said Mr Tolley's quality coffee making showed off his exceptional skills.
The awards were introduced 11 years ago to recognise baristas that are really going above and beyond, Mr Van Hattum said.
He expected the finals to be "hotly contested".
Wild Bean Cafe is the largest retailer of Fairtrade coffee and hot chocolate with 81 outlets nationwide, using beans from Costa Rica, Brazil and Mexico.