The report claims the Resource Management Act's consent process already requires "rigorous evaluation" into the possible effects of mining, and therefore is "precautionary". There was not enough information, or proof of a lack of measures preventing adverse, on which to base a plan change, the report said.
But MineWatch Northland spokesman Tim Howard said the mining-related responses sidestepped the issue of toxic waste and its potential legacy.
Protecting water from contamination by toxic waste should be one of the highest priorities in Northland, Mr Howard said.
"Hard-rock mining creates vast amounts of tailings dust that is heavily contaminated with heavy metals like mercury, cadmium and arsenic," he said.
"This dust must be kept wet and be stored forever in huge dams. These dams can fail in natural disasters, or simply due to poor design or maintenance. Even stable tailings dams must overflow during heavy rain leaking contaminates into groundwater."
It is understood Australian company De Grey Mining Ltd will start drilling three 500 metre core samples at Puhipuhi soon, and intends doing the same amount of drilling next year.