"It seems like the logical thing to do. That area is under a tribal claim of Ngati Kuta and Patukeha," Mr Willoughby said. "There was a village there. The name of that village was called Wairoa and it had a reasonable community. They had a lot of gardens there and grew vegetables to service the village. Through various ways the land was taken off the Maori."
Mr Willoughby said in 2009, koiwi (human remains) believed to have been Maori remains were exposed along Elliot Bay after a storm. He said it reinforced that the site was one of cultural historic heritage.
He said local hapu had a good relationship with John Elliot and were concerned about what might happen if the land was sold on the open market.
"He's lived amongst us for a long time and we've been coexisting quite nicely, we understand his position too. What we don't want to happen to the farm is it go out on the open market and eventually it gets broken up and it goes out of the hands of the local community."
A spokeswoman for the Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations said the Crown sometimes bought properties if there was a willing seller, the land was of particular importance to the claimant group and it fitted within their commercial and cultural aspirations for settlement.
She said the Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations, Chris Finlayson, had asked officials to consider options relating to the use of the Elliot Bay property in Treaty settlements.