At the end of the year the group was planning to re-introduce Duvaucel's gecko to Okahu Island. Growing up to 30cm long, Duvaucel's gecko is New Zealand's largest lizard. It is the country's largest reptile after the tuatara.
Mr Robbins said Okahu had been chosen because it was furthest from the mainland and there were no plans to relocate any forest birds, which could eat young geckos, to Okahu.
Because of its size there was little chance Duvaucel's gecko had survived while pests were still on the islands.
A recent reptile survey on Okahu had found only shore skinks but what appeared to be gecko footprints had been seen on Urupukapuka, the largest island in the group. A reptile survey would be carried out on Moturua, where the Pacific gecko was seen, to see what else had clung on.
Moturua was the scene of a predator scare earlier this year when a cat jumped off a yacht and swam to the island. It took three weeks to catch the cat using a cage trap baited with tinned tuna.
Project Island Song is a community-led initiative to restore native flora and fauna to the Ipipiri islands. It brings together conservation group Guardians of the Bay of Islands, the Department of Conservation, Rawhiti hapu and island landowners. Species re-introduced so far include the tieke (saddleback), popokatea (whitehead) and toutouwai (North Island robin).