A Cuisine expert summarised the restaurant as having smart surrounds, sea views and great food, but behind the scenes there were plenty of other factors at work.
"It's just about day to day consistency and quality, those are the biggest things," Mr Jones said.
A chef's hat rating system already used by Good Food Guides in Australia, was adopted by Cuisine this year.
Its significance was not lost on Mr Jones: "the hat is recognised internationally, I started off at hatted restaurants in Sydney, so to have that awarded to us in New Zealand is quite something," he said.
Elephant Hill has featured in the Good Food Guide for about four years, but this was the first time they had won a category.
It was too soon to say whether the award would be a boost for business.
"I think it will be interesting to see how it goes, I think it will be a slow trickle, I don't think it will be immediate - but it's all part of the growth."
An aside to the award, was a sophisticated winter F.A.W.C! Chefs in Homes event, being held tonight.
People get the opportunity to step inside The Lodge, an exclusive home situated behind Elephant Hill where Mr Jones will prepare a sublime seven course dinner.
"It will be a fairly casual thing where people can watch us cook and ask questions, " he said.