The face-off was filmed to help showcase Auckland to the thousands of athletes who will travel to New Zealand for the Games.
The athletes began with a round of archery at Cornwall Park followed by a golfing challenge with ocean views at Muriwai in West Auckland.
They then tackled a mountainbike trail and rounded off the mini-masters event with a waka ama race at Takapuna Beach.
Hickey said that despite his pain, he took comfort in the knowledge that, unlike Hutchings, he did not fall out of his waka.
“I was supposed to be The Old Man of the Sea, not The Old Man in the Sea,” Hutchings said.
“The cold water helped my recovery after the previous challenges so I wasn’t too upset.”
World Masters Games 2017 chief executive Jennah Wootten said the pair were good sports during the challenge and, as ambassadors of the Games, they helped communicate the message that masters sport was not just for much older people.
“You can be a masters athlete in your 20s. And you can be a masters athlete for the enjoyment as much as the competitive factor. It’s an incredibly inclusive event.”
The World Masters Games had a relatively low profile in New Zealand, but overseas masters sport at competitive level was held in high regard, she said.
“We are a sporting nation, but New Zealand does fall short when it comes to participation later in life. We’re hoping the World Masters Games 2017 will galvanise Kiwis to reconsider the role that sport plays in their lives.”
Registrations for the World Masters Games 2017 are due to open in February 2016. Both Hutchings and Hickey plan to enter.