Movie studios, record companies and other rights holders are the beneficiaries of a new copyright regime and should bear the cost of its set-up, says a District Court judge specialising in technology.
The Government's "three strikes" copyright system comes into force on September 1 and requires internet companies to issue warning notices to customers suspected of illegally downloading material, if rights holders request it.
After a customer has been issued a third notice, rights holders can bring the case before the Copyright Tribunal, which can slap an offender with a fine of up to $15,000.
Commerce Minister Simon Power announced last week internet providers (ISPs) will be able to charge copyright holders a fee of $25 for every notice they issue. This was much higher than the $2 suggested by groups representing movie companies such as Warner Bros - the studio putting money into Peter Jackson's The Hobbit.
The Government said the $25 fee would allow ISPs to recover a "reasonable proportion" of expenses involved with implementing the law. But according to one internet company, Orcon, the cost of dealing with each notice could be as high as $76 and the cost of installing systems to cope with the new regime sits at $50,000.
Judge David Harvey, an expert on IT law, argued it was "just and equitable" for rights holders, rather than ISPs, to shoulder the system's set-up costs.
"Fees set should include either set-up costs or alternatively a substantial contribution to set-up costs by rights owners," he wrote in a submission to the Ministry of Economic Development. Harvey, who was making the comments in a personal capacity, said the benefits of the scheme sat solely with rights owners.
"The benefit and advantage is solely for rights owners and provides a quick and cheap system of enforcement as an alternative to expensive and time-consuming enforcement proceedings in court ... [ISPs] are now cast into an enforcement role that is not consistent with their traditional business model," he said.
AdvertisementAdvertise with NZME.
Latest from Business
AI boom drives sharemarkets to best first quarter in five years
World stocks rise 7.7% as optimism about US economy offsets expectations of rate cuts.