Lincoln Tan

Lincoln Tan is the New Zealand Herald’s diversity, ethnic affairs and immigration senior reporter.

Migrants in NZ trapped in forced labour: US official

The US office says child-trafficking victims in NZ engage in prostitution and are sometimes controlled by gangs. File photo / NZ Herald
The US office says child-trafficking victims in NZ engage in prostitution and are sometimes controlled by gangs. File photo / NZ Herald

A senior United States government official claims underage girls are subjected to sex trafficking and migrants trapped into forced labour here, and describes New Zealand's way of defining human trafficking as "misplaced".

Immigration New Zealand is maintaining there are no substantiated cases of people trafficking here because those crossing the border who come here to work in the sex trade or do manual labour are not being forced into doing so.

Unlike many countries, New Zealand does not recognise domestic cases as trafficking.

"Such a focus on initial consent is misplaced," said Mr Luis Cdebaca, who was appointed by US President Barack Obama to direct the Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons at the Department of State.

He serves as senior adviser to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, and was in New Zealand this year to study trafficking here.

"Whether a person migrated for a particular job or participated in an activity willingly is legally irrelevant under the UN Trafficking Protocol if they are subsequently kept in the service through force, threats, or psychological manipulation," he said.

Last year a sex worker who came on a visitor's visa told another prostitute at a central Auckland brothel where she worked that she had been made to work 16-hour shifts with few breaks.

Another sex worker who was lured here with a $4500 cash offer plus airfares was later told it was a loan she had to repay.

Both women had their passports taken away from them, and in one case the police had to be called in to retrieve the passport from the brothel owner.

But under New Zealand's definition, these did not constitute human trafficking.

"As most foreign trafficking victims have not yet fallen into the trap when they are in transit, border interdiction is less effective than interior enforcement, and diverts resources from the proactive field investigation that needs to be done in order to uncover this hidden crime," Mr Cdebaca said. He said robust victim identification practices should be made a top priority as victims rarely came forward.

The latest Trafficking in Persons report identified New Zealand as a source country for underage girls in sex trafficking and a destination country for foreign men and women in forced labour.

"New Zealand is reportedly a destination country for women from Asian countries, such as Hong Kong, Thailand, Taiwan and China, and Eastern Europe trafficked into forced prostitution," the report said.

"Child trafficking victims are found engaging in prostitution illegally in brothels and off the street, some being controlled by local gangs."

Mr Cdebaca said he stood by the findings of the report: "The Trafficking in Persons Report speaks for itself."

Immigration's general manager (risk and integrity) Steve Stuart defended New Zealand's definition of trafficking, and said it complied with international obligations as a signatory to the UN convention against Transnational Organised Crime and the associated Protocol to Prevent and Suppress Trafficking in Persons.

"While the cross-border element of our legal definition differs from other countries, we believe it is appropriate given our size and geographical location," Mr Stuart said.

"New Zealand has a strong stance on people trafficking and has comprehensive anti-trafficking legislation."

Penalties for trafficking in persons include imprisonment of up to 20 years or a fine of $500,000 or both.

The Crimes Act and Immigration Act also include measures to punish activities such as abduction, assault, kidnapping, coercing prostitutes and exploiting labourers.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a5 at 28 Jul 2014 17:28:29 Processing Time: 481ms