His first kick - after 11 minutes - brought up 1400 test points. He is the first to reach that milestone and it is a fitting reward for his excellence over such a sustained period. Last night was his 96th test after he made his debut against Wales way back in 2003.
He likes the big stage and enjoys the pressure and that's a good thing because All Blacks coach Steve Hansen acknowledged Carter is under the gun to retain his place in the face of the continuing challenges from Aaron Cruden and Beauden Barrett, in particular.
There was no sign of the calf problem which kept him out of the first two Rugby Championship tests and he gave a reminder of the threat he still possesses when embarking on the run from his 22m line which ended in Smith's second try.
There was a forward pass to start with - though the transfer to Julian Savea could have been considered straight - and an offload to a Pumas player. It was that sort of match.
His last act was to convert Savea's try before being replaced by Barrett in the 55th minute - it was always Hansen's plan to replace Carter due to his lack of recent match time.
Up and down, yes, but Carter will still be one of the first names in Hansen's starting line-up for next Saturday's test against the Springboks at Eden Park. His calmness under pressure and experience make him invaluable still and the rare sight of Richie McCaw limping off in the second half last night could make those attributes even more important next weekend.