In a shining moment, it was conflict and denouncement between the then-greatest player in the world and the man who in coming years would assume his mantle.
"Brad Fittler's a freak and freaks can do anything," commentator David Fordham exclaimed.
Today, after 336 first-grade games, two premierships, three World Cups, 31 Origins and 40 tests, Freddy may just hold his own with those young bucks on Eden Park.
The last thing an old boxer loses is his punch - for a league player it is his guile.
It is not like the game isn't littered with wondrous examples of "grandads" suiting up for one last hurrah.
The whole success of State of Origin can be directly attributed to the giant Arthur Beetson - about to be dropped to Sydney's reserve grade competition he was tapped to captain his native Queensland in the first-ever game in 1980.
At 35, Beetson proved the detractors of the "pointless, friendly game" wrong by belting his own Parramatta clubmates in the shellshocked New South Wales line-up from pillar to post in an inspired performance that made "mate against mate" become a tagline for the ages.
Choosing yesterday's champions to do the business one more time worked again for Queensland in the 2001 series - also Fittler's initial NSW retirement.
Maroon's coach Wayne Bennett arranged for 34-year-old Allan Langer to fly back under an assumed name from England to play at halfback for the game three decider, and "Alfie" dominated proceedings by laying on three tries in the first half to whisk the Cane Toads away.
For Kiwi fans it couldn't get much better than the Gary Freeman Testimonial match in 1995, when at 40 years old Freeman's former test skipper Mark Graham proved in 40 minutes that time could not dull the Hall of Fame hard man's skills.
"Mark Graham ... it's like turning the clock back," the commentator enthused as the legendary back rower set up smart tries with silky offloads against Kangaroo players fresh off winning the 1995 World Cup.
Never underestimate the value of beautiful nostalgia in the Greatest Game of All.
If Freddy wants one more ride, I say let him saddle that pony.