She also spoke of her regret that the hotel had not been granted historic protection when it turned 100.
Mr Macauley described the pub as his turangawaewae during his first years in town. He recalled the "absolute legends" who could be found propping up the bar most nights, the founding of the Kaikohe Lions over a few pints in 1965 and the infamous 4am club, so named because its members could not leave before 4am.
"There's a lot of history in this place. It's a crying shame to see it reduced to a state where it will no longer grace the main street," he said.
Kaumatua Te Wati Erueti remembered his time as a barman under long-time hotel manager Colin McKenzie and working his way up to a job behind the private bar.
After a blessing by Ratana minister William Smith and Anglican reverend Kuini Matene, the crowd walked to Bank Bar for a final drink in honour of their old watering hole and a fundraising auction of hotel memorabilia. All proceeds from the event will go to Kaikohe St John. About 150 people were expected.
The original plan was to have a final drink in the old bar but that was vetoed by Te Runanga-a-nui o Ngapuhi, which bought the derelict hotel for just over $280,000 and has a firm no-alcohol policy.
Once the hotel has been demolished the site will be grassed over until the runanga comes up with a plan for the prime Broadway site.