But Mrs Karl was quick thinking and employed her mum and a friend with artistic skills, and together they transformed him into a giant Northland rugby player. Since then he has remained graffiti-free. "He's been fine ever since."
Well, that was until Thursday night when thieves targeted Gammie and ripped his legs from under him. Mrs Karl thought it was at least a two-man heist, and a truck or trailer would have been needed to carry him away.
"He is really heavy. This is not a random theft, it needed a bit of planning to get away with him."
The theft was reported to Dargaville police yesterday morning.
"Even if you give him a paint job, what are you going to do with him?" Mrs Karl questioned.
But her immediate blitz on social media contributed to Gammie's discovery on a side road off Pukeatua yesterday. A friend who knew a friend knew about the theft, and then Gammie was discovered discarded.
"He's been dumped down a bank. We're not sure if there's any damage but my husband will go and get him and put him back."
The couple are staunch Taniwha supporters and are hoping for a better season than last from the boys in Cambridge blue.
"We're loyal to the bitter end no matter how they do."