Terralink managing director Mike Donald said 2011 was not the year of economic recovery New Zealand property owners had hoped for.
"What we're looking for is a sustained downward trend - right now we're experiencing the opposite," he said.
"In December 2011 there were 223 mortgagee sales, or more than seven per day.
"That's the second-highest ever recorded for a December, and just 49 fewer than December 2009 when New Zealand was at the height of recession."
He said some groups and regions were being hit harder than others.
"Looking behind the numbers, we see the proportion of individuals with a single property facing mortgagee sales increased in 2011, up from 19 per cent in 2010 to 22 per cent in 2011.
"This is equal to the same record high for individuals in 2009. Also, it's more than likely these sales are for family homes, not rentals or investments.
"More Mum and Dad property owners are losing their homes. It's hard to claim things are getting better for ordinary Kiwis while this trend continues."
While some regions experienced a decrease in the number of mortgagee sales, other regions kept rising. Marlborough's mortgagee sales were the highest, up 83 per cent.
Mr Donald said the 2012 outlook was grim, with preliminary figures for January and February indicating mortgagee sales significantly higher than for the same period last year.
Terralink derives its mortgagee sales data from legal registrations of actual foreclosures.