"It's not about the type of school," he said. "It's about the impact on existing schools.
"I'm really holding-out until I hear more from the minister." Mr Foss expects the answers from Minister of Education Hekia Parata today or tomorrow.
"Yes, caught on the hop, it's a surprise," Mr Foss said.
Mr Dixon was aware Arataki had been bought by the ministry several years ago as a site for a new school, in anticipation of growth in the rolls of such schools as Te Mata Primary.
"That didn't happen," said Mr Dixon, who describes the placing of a kura kaupapa on the site as "bizarre".
In a letter to the editor of Hawke's Bay Today, he asked five questions.
"What is the optimum roll for the new kura and how many of these students (aged 5-18) will actually live in Havelock North ?" he asked.
"Where are the additional students going to come from and how are they going to get there?
"What expense is going to incur on a weekly basis on transportation?"
He questioned whether any opinions had been sought and asked: "What consultation has been carried out with local residents, educationalists and iwi as to the suitability of this location?
"What other locations within the Hastings District have been considered?
"Is it going to be the first Charter School in Hawkes Bay? Will common sense prevail?" Mr Dixon asked.