He said there are multiple issues, including not knowing five weeks out what restrictions would be in place, who could come and what they might compete in, uncertainty of costs for the event and for those taking part, and contact-tracing when, by the nature of the shearing industry, competitors and officials could be dispersing widely and quickly afterwards.
"It's better to pull the pin now," he said, but added there are still hopes of staging the show's secondary schools event on the middle day of the October 21-23 show and a second Women in Wool charity event, held for the first time last year with women who have stepped out of such careers as dentistry, optometry, accountancy, livestock agency and other professions to learn to shear.
The shears have been central to Hawke's Bay's rise to international acclaim in shearing sports, with Hawke's Bay shearers Cam Ferguson, Rowland Smith and John Kirkpatrick having become world champions and, along with Dion King, another from the Bay, winning at least one Golden Shears Open title each. Several Great Raihania Shears Open woolhandling winners have also been world champions.
A&P society general manager Sally Jackson, who last week announced plans for a competitors-only show, said the society remained committed to providing a show for the competitors while safeguarding the future of a show which in most years has an operating budget of several hundred thousand dollars.
At least four other A&P shows in the new season throughout New Zealand have already been cancelled this year because of the Covid crisis.