Its hours of 7am to 10.30am were said to be unpopular with Saturday shoppers.
Ms McDade said surrounding retailers asked for the later hours because it attracted more people to their shops.
The largest volume of foot traffic occurred after 10am, forcing market vendors to turn away customers in time for the road to be reopened.
The later start did not halt shopper and vendor decline and the decision was made to move to the Mall, in sight of both Heretaunga St East and West, with the added attraction of no street closure.
The idea of Business Association chairman Michael Whittaker, the market courted more controversy after local supermarkets stopped stocking his Te Mata Mushroom Company produce, which Foodstuffs said was not in retaliation for his support of the market.
Apple Fest includes a month-long Apple Trail highlighting businesses in Hastings District that work with apples and a family carnival on March 19.