Meanwhile, a Countdown spokeswoman said "it is not unusual to see these popular Easter foods on the shelves at the same time each year, in early January."
Both Countdown and Hastings Pakn'Save said hot cross buns were one of their most popular items in the lead up to Easter, and supported the early production decisions.
"We sell millions of hot cross buns and they are in hot demand right from the time they go on sale," said a Countdown spokeswoman.
Hastings Pakn'Save store owner, Brendon Smith said, "it is what the customers want, as they love them."
Allegations about Countdown beginning baking early to use up the old Christmas mince mix for the buns was defended by the spokeswoman.
"The mix used was not the same and was completely different."
Although Hastings New World haven't stocked their shelves with the popular Easter treat, store manager Dan Shaw said it would not be far off.
"We are probably looking at a couple of weeks away."
Whether it is too early or not, customers who welcomed the January hot cross bun faze are in luck, with a few months to go yet.