Hawke's Bay A beat Auckland-based Morningstar 10-5 with Coddington, 34, scoring all 10 of the Bay's goals. Old timers among the spectators couldn't remember the last time one player scored 10 in a Dewar Cup fixture but Coddington wasn't getting too carried away with the feat.
"It's a team game and the whole team was on the ball," Coddington remarked.
He agreed Vowles' assists were spot on.
Hawke's Bay A were always in front but Morningstar stayed in touch.
The Aucklanders trailed by three on two occasions.
"The Aucklanders were no mugs. They play in a strong club competition up there and they had a couple of professionals too," Thompson said.
He was full of praise for the manner in which Vowles and Coddington combined in the first outing together since playing for Hawke's Bay at last year's Savile Cup tournament.
"At the same time there were occasions when we just put JC [Coddington] into space and hung back on defence American football style.
You heard the ground announcer ... he said JC walked on water today. That was definitely the case ... it was his day."
A polo player for 16 years, Coddington, is playing in his ninth Dewar Cup tournament and while he was a member of the winning Wanstead team five years ago, Coddington, has yet to pose in a winning Dewar Cup team photo with a Hawke's Bay side.
"Today's win will give us confidence but like in most sports winning titles is an on-the-day thing," Coddington said. In 2008 he played No1 for New Zealand in an 8-3 win against Malaysia in Hastings.
Another of his highlights is winning the Savile Cup, the country's most prestigious polo trophy, with an Auckland team which included Kiwi legend Cody Forsyth.
Coddington has another stint in England during the Kiwi winter and has been back playing in New Zealand since October. He will return to England again in March.
Hawke's Bay A have a rest today and a win against Rangitikei B tomorrow will secure a berth in Sunday's final of the seven-team Dewar Cup grade.
Six teams are playing in the Nelson Cup low goal section which begins today.