But CD skipper William Young soldiered on, making the stubborn ND batsmen face every ball past the 6pm deadline although it was pretty obvious the equation stopped favouring the gallant Knights even as early as tea.
The promise of victory was there. Even the rain stayed away but CD couldn't reel in 20 wickets in four days for the inevitable draw to leave them winless.
So did it leave CD feeling like they had lost?
Smith said CD played all the cricket and players felt "very content with the way they performed".
"It'll give them good momentum and confidence going into the T20s," he said ahead of their first match against Canterbury Kings in New Plymouth on December 4.
A century each to Dane Cleaver and Tom Bruce and a five-wicket haul for spinner Ajaz Patel were highlights.
Wicketkeeper Cleaver also took six catches in a game that pitted him against ND's Tim Seifert - the pair seen as successors to ageing Black Caps glovemen.
NZC yesterday revealed the quake-affected round four CD v Wellington game will not be replayed due to "logistical complications that have made the option of re-scheduling the match impractical".
The teams will be awarded five competition points each, based on the average tally of the total points (20) the other four teams collected during the round.
In other Plunket Shield matches yesterday, the Kings beat the Auckland Aces by 10 runs in Rangiora while the Otago Volts and the Firebirds had to settle for a draw in Dunedin.
That means ND retain their top-rung status while CD pull themselves up from last place for a perch above the Volts.
Standings: ND 59pts, Canterbury 49, Wellington 47, Auckland 41, CD 28, Otago 23.