Young top scored with 63 runs, reaching a milestone 1000 List A runs on 62, and Mr Reliable Joshua Clarkson added 44.
Rookie Navin Patel (37 runs), Ajaz Patel (31 not out) and Kieran Noema-Barnett (29) contributed but Young said none of the CD offerings added up to match-winning statements.
"It's very disappointing not to get to our target but credit to Otago who used their bowlers very well and never really let us get a substantial partnership together," Young lamented.
"To be honest, the contributions [at the end] were too little too late."
Young said it was imperative someone in the top four had to lay down the platform for any respectable total.
"If you want to win the Ford Trophy you've got to back yourself to chase down 280 on a flat wicket."
In just his second List A game, opening seamer Liam Dudding 3-67 after a wicket-less (0-63) debut in the four-run DL Method loss to the Aces.
Spinner Ajaz Patel was the most frugal (2-38) for his best figures (previous 1-51).
"Ajaz was asked to bowl two of his overs in the top 10 and then I brought him back in the middle and sort of picked up where he left off. Jazz is bowling with a lot of confidence and it's coming out really well."
Navin Patel also posted a highest score, eclipsing his unbeaten 19.
CD play Wellington Firebirds at the Basin Reserve on Wednesday but can ill afford inclement weather abandoning play.