We thought that might be a little early for the home decorations, but Pam pointed out: "If I'm going to all the effort of putting up lights and all my festive things, I'm going to enjoy them for more than three weeks."
Sharon said: "I think about the end of October, except craft shops for those who want to make things, which can take a bit longer."
A couple argued it would be better to keep it just in December, while one listener thought starting the advertising and playing Christmas tunes on the radio should be banned until December 18, giving us just six days to prepare.
While that might be a little extreme, Sarah certainly agrees that this time of year is far too early.
Martin agreed too, until he realised that, as a man who celebrates his birthday every half-year and insists on having a birthday month instead of just a day, he's not really in a position to judge.