With the light fading and Kibur keen to finish the round and get back to Tauranga, Stevens called off his search, dropped another ball and chipped on to the green. As he was about to pull the pin out his missing ball revealed itself.
"I looked in and was instantly in shock. I stepped back and said to Warren 'my ball's in the hole', and he said "don't give me that bull****".' With no one playing directly in front of them Stevens can't explain how his tee shot found its way into the hole.
"We obviously didn't see what happened but it must've taken a fairly decent bounce, gone left and rolled up on to the green, although there's been a few mates suggest there's probably a little dog that runs around the course putting balls into the hole."
Hole-in-one odds are in the neighbourhood of 13,000-to-one for the average golfer, but for an albatross ace those odds skyrocket to 1,000,000-to-one.
India's Rahil Gangjee on Monday became the third player in Nationwide Tour history to make a hole-in-one on a par 4, using his driver to ace the 316-yard 15th at the Mylan Classic.
Tauranga's Josh Geary, playing in the same tournament, had already achieved the feat, in 2003 as an amateur, when his tee shot at Whakatane's 295m par-four third hole rolled up on to the green at the Bay Open and plonked in the hole. Stevens' ace was the second at Katikati's Golf Pacifica that week, with Omokoroa 18-handicapper Lynly Hills hitting the perfect shot two days earlier on the 101m par three 9th.
Stevens' second phone call after ringing his girlfriend was to his parents, both long-time members of the hole-in-one fraternity.
His form leading up to his greatest day in golf had been patchy - 105 at the Lake Resort in Pauanui and 85 and 105 at Emerald Lakes on the Gold Coast. His hole-in-one helped him to an 85 at Pacifica.
"I love the game and would play every day if I could, but it's a hugely frustrating sport. Some days I hit the ball straight and other days I'm all over the place, and if the odds of an ace on a par four are so huge then I was due one because I must've had nearly a million shots on the golf course."