''We've had plenty of people ask us if it's for sale but we've never had it taken before.''
She put a post on Facebook about the missing trolley and was contacted the next morning by someone offering to buy a new one for the shop.
Gill arranged to meet the person at the shop the next day and as she walked toward the door, she saw a trolley by the storage shed.
''I thought, this is the new trolley, she's been already and I've missed her.''
But closer inspection revealed it was the old trolley. In broad daylight, the trolley had been returned in just the same condition as when it disappeared.
Gill was able to get a message to the person buying the new trolley, who was already at Te Puke Mitre 10.
''She was on the way out to the car with it, but I was able to meet her - she was really good about it.''
Now the trolley is still kept outside the shop in its usual place, but its handle is padlocked to, rather than hooked over, the tap.