So Omanu only needed one point for victory.
Mount's Judy Cameron fought back from three down with six holes to play against Debbie Noble to win two up on the 18th and secure a point. Gillian Lees struggled with her short game against Susie-Jane Hikairo, but three wins on the last three holes (including a clutch 15-foot birdie on the 17th) secured a half point in her match.
Then Kate Davidson stepped up to the mark and won her match against Taylor-Rose on the 18th.
With the final score a draw, a playoff was agreed so Kate Davidson volunteered to take on Alanna and the two teed off in semi-darkness back down the 18th.
Kate hit a monster drive down the fairway and a nine iron 120m through the back of the green. Alanna also hit her approach through the back of the green resulting in both players having awkward downhill chips.
Kate chipped her shot within two feet of the pin, while Alanna went past the pin by 5 feet, horseshoeing her putt out the back of the hole. The gallery shone torches onto the green for the players to putt as Kate sank her putt in convincing fashion.
Omanu had previously won the trophy three times (and Rotorua seven times) since the trophy's inception in 2007.