Marcel Collett also impressed with a half century. With the visitors needing four runs for victory, they were dismissed with the last ball of the game to hand Poverty Bay a three run win.
The Bay development side will only have to look back to last year's Basil McBurney competition game against Hamilton for inspiration.
The game went down to the wire with Hamilton needing six for victory off the last over.
A four from the last ball off the contest wasn't enough, with the Bay side elated to defeat Hamilton for the first time since 2010.
There is just one change in the Bay of Plenty second XI from the team that travelled to Poverty Bay, with Ben Pomare replacing Josh Earle.
Bay of Plenty development team to play Hamilton
Dominic Crombie (captain), Fergus Lellman, Taylor Bettelheim, Blair McKenzie, Marcel Collett, Gurwinder Singh, Ben Pomare, Jacob Logan, Iman Singh, Cameron Riley, Craig Boyd, Craig Baldry.
Coach: Russell Williams. Manager: Shaun Riley.
Bay of Plenty development team - 2018/19 Results
Poverty Bay 239/9 (N Hendrie 72, R Tallot 42, Craig Baldry 3/28, Iman Singh 2/35, James Boyd 2/36) beat Bay of Plenty Development 236 (Jacob Logan 72, Marcel Collett 59, D Thompson 4/45, I Singh 3/15)
- Supplied content