Accused dad saved baby, court told

By Katie Holland of The Daily Post -
File Photo / NZ Herald
File Photo / NZ Herald

A man accused of shaking, slapping and throwing his 4-month-old son around was a good father who loved his children, a court has been told.

Robert Haami Boynton, 39, from Matahi Valley, is on trial in the High Court at Rotorua for violent offences against his former partner Ngarangi Wickliffe and their son.

The violence is alleged to have occurred between October 1, 2009, and May 19, 2011.

On the opening day of the trial Boynton pleaded guilty to one charge of assaulting a female and on Tuesday pleaded guilty to another identical charge - both against Ms Wickliffe.

Boynton has pleaded not guilty to committing grievous bodily harm with intent against his son and the alternative charge, added during the trial, of causing grievous bodily harm with reckless disregard for his son's safety. These relate to an incident on April 28, 2011 when the baby, while in the care of his father, suffered serious brain injuries. Boynton has denied two other charges of assaulting with intent to injure and assault - relating to earlier incidents where it's alleged he slapped, shook and threw the baby 2m on to a thin mattress.

He has also denied a charge of assaulting Ms Wickliffe with intent to injure, one of assaulting her and one charge of attempting to pervert the cause of justice by threatening her.

In his closing address yesterday, Tauranga Crown solicitor Greg Hollister-Jones described Boynton as a man with a "short and violent temper" that escalated to violence over seemingly minor issues.

Mr Hollister-Jones said that on April 28 Boynton was stressed and angry as Ms Wickliffe had left him and the teething baby days earlier. He said at 6pm that day Boynton went into his crying but otherwise healthy son's bedroom and came back 20-30 seconds later holding the seriously concussed baby.

Boynton had a history of "snapping" when his baby cried.

Mr Hollister-Jones said a doctor had testified the concussion could have been caused by shaking, slamming him on to a surface or a combination of both. The haemorrhaging in the baby's eyes was said to be more serious than you would see from a high speed motor accident.

Boynton's lawyer Tony Rickard-Simms said his client had accepted his shortcomings and was not proud of slapping and pushing Ms Wickliffe. However, he denied allegations he intended to injure her or that he had harmed his baby.

"He loves his children, all of them. He is very proud of them," said Mr Rickard-Simms.

When Boynton heard the baby cry he recognised something was not right, so he brought the baby straight back out and asked friends for help. An ambulance was then called.

"We say he in fact saved his baby's life that night."

For more articles from this region, go to

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a1 at 23 Jul 2014 03:02:49 Processing Time: 504ms