This week, Evgeny Morozov, an academic with a book to promote, lambasted Google as a company "run by adolescents", apparently oblivious to the fact that Eric Schmidt, Larry Page and Sergey Brin are 57, 40, and 39 respectively.
This is all pure codswallop, of course. Google is the most powerful and successful company in the world - poorer than Apple, but much more influential - because no firm anywhere, ever, has more cleverly innovated to give consumers precisely what they want at an astonishingly low price (i.e. free).
It is, in other words, the best example of entrepreneurship and capitalism yet invented, and it strikes me as weird, to put it mildly, that people who usually applaud those things have taken against this particular firm.
Still, let's humour them briefly, and address those concerns in full:
• Google destroys privacy. Well, only if you let it, for instance by dancing topless when you see one of its Street View cars charging towards you. Otherwise, you're usually okay.
• Google destroys conversation. A conversation has to be real bad for you to be on your, say, iPhone instead. Maybe talk to somebody else? Also: if anyone is to blame for this, it's Steve Jobs.
• Google makes us depend on "augmented reality". That sounds pretty fly. Where do I sign up?
• Google searches are a substitute for real thinking. Yes, but thinking is tiring, and takes much longer.
And, er, that's about it. Most of the people who don't like Google avail themselves of its services for free, constantly. I bet moody Mr Morozov searched thousands of times on Google's engine in the course of writing his tome.
Like other Googlephobes, he ought to try boycotting the company's products for a while before preaching hypocritically about its sins.
- Independent