TV Review: Firstline

By Deborah Hill Cone

Rachel Smalley is a class act. Photo / Supplied
Rachel Smalley is a class act. Photo / Supplied

It is hard to watch TV3's new breakfast news show Firstline without thinking about the NZ Herald's big scoop this week that we taxpayers had given TV3's owner a $43 million loan. Aren't we generous, eh?

It makes one feel a bit proprietorial about the broadcaster. So Mediaworks, what are we getting for our largesse? From this week, thankfully, we received a big dose of host Rachel Smalley from 6am to 8.30am.

Firstline is a real news show which doesn't have segments about whether Marmite or Vegemite is better or wacky banter about fruity reporters' private lives.

I have to disclose, straight up, that I am not one of those news snobs who say they read only The Economist and watch the BBC. I can appreciate good reporting, whether it is highbrow, lowbrow or dirty old tabloid. I thought Paul Henry was really funny. Most of the time. But the New Zealand news landscape has changed since the Christchurch earthquake and all of a sudden the bubbly, breezy tone of TVNZ's Breakfast show, wrapped around serious news - as though viewers need a spoonful of sugar to help the medicine go down - seems wrong-headed.

TV3's promise to offer "Just the news, ma'am" without rictus-grin repartee seems more respectful of viewers' intelligence. And I am not saying this just because I have a girl-crush on Rachel Smalley. Smalley, who returned to New Zealand from a newsreading gig at Sky News UK, has a Hitchcock-blonde intelligence that seems to give our news the gravitas it deserves. So Firstline promises to be grown-up news.

Even local journalists used to scoff at our parish-pump news judgments; cats up trees, holiday snaps shown so the owner of a lost camera can be found. But not any more. The Christchurch earthquake has "blooded" us and the news will never be the same.

Even so, it is a ballsy call by the TV3 news bosses to go with "naked" news. They unashamedly recycle the material in Firstline across the 2 1/2 hours. I'm not sure why the networks have been squeamish about this before. Who has the time in the morning to watch TV for 2 1/2 hours straight? Unless you are a reviewer, of course.

I did just that and found the content much less po-faced than the purist bulletins I had expected. "They're not people and they're not churches but don't underestimate what they mean to the people of Christchurch," opened reporter Ali Ikram in a quirky piece about arborists chopping down trees which had been damaged by the quake. A live cross by Smalley to reporter Hamish Clark saw the Christchurch-based journalist joking about yet another aftershock. "We rattled, rolled and rumbled. It was a good one, although I shouldn't laugh," said Clark, laughing.

After a serious story about UK entrepreneur Hamish Egston donating $4 million to earthquake recovery, there was another offbeat piece; an investigation into Christchurch mayor Bob Parker's parka. The brightly coloured anorak even has its own fan page on Facebook.

Sometime-poet and TV3 reporter Richard Langston waxed lyrical next in an item about Scott, a Christchurch locksmith. "Scott is more than a locksmith, he is also a counsellor," said Langston. Scott: "You feel quite buggered at the end of the day but you're helping people."

About now Firstline went to an advertising break. I rather wished they hadn't. The only ad was for the Ab Circle Pro, a device that B-grade reality TV star Audrina Partridge, whoever she is, depends on to "stay red-carpet ready". I am ready to bet class act Smalley doesn't get on this ridiculous contraption before coming to work.

C'mon Mediaworks advertising department! With a substantial commitment from management to proper news and $43 million of "our" money, surely you could come up with some better backing than this? Perhaps an ad for the Government: "This news broadcast was bought to you by you. Cheers, thanks a lot."

* Firstline plays on TV3, weekdays from 6am to 8.30am.

- Herald on Sunday

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


Have your say

1200 characters left

By and large our readers' comments are respectful and courteous. We're sure you'll fit in well.
View commenting guidelines.

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2015, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 27 Nov 2015 00:29:59 Processing Time: 217ms