Isaac Davison

Isaac Davison is a NZ Herald political reporter.

PM against any 'silly' legal action

John Key tells Conservation Minister that taking on environmental advocate in court is not productive.

Nick Smith says he'll take the PM's advice on board. Photo / APN
Nick Smith says he'll take the PM's advice on board. Photo / APN

Prime Minister John Key says Conservation Minister Nick Smith would be "silly" to take legal action against an environmental advocate who accused him of political interference.

Mr Key said he had spoken briefly to the minister and backed Dr Smith's account of a meeting with the Fish and Game Council, an independent advocacy group.

Several people who attended the meeting on July 18 said Dr Smith behaved like a bully, described the council as a "rabid NGO [non-governmental organisation]" and threatened to limit its role if it did not "tone down" its criticism of irrigation and agriculture - a key part of National's economic agenda.

Dr Smith rejected these claims and said he was considering legal action against one of the critics, Association of Freshwater Anglers president David Haynes.

Mr Key told reporters he would not support this move: "My advice would be [that would be] a step too far, it would be a little bit silly.

"In the end, he obviously feels offended by the comments that have been made ... but history tells you that it's not a very productive step to take."

Dr Smith told the Herald he would "take the Prime Minister's advice on board". He had asked his lawyer for advice because he felt Mr Haynes had deliberately misrepresented his comments.

Some at the meeting said they were given the impression that if they did not pull back on their criticism of irrigation and "dirty dairying" the minister would restructure the organisation through a legislation change.

Mr Haynes told Radio New Zealand: "From my perspective it was very [clear] they were being castigated. It could be construed as political interference - this was about telling Fish and Game to wind their neck in."

Watch: Anne Gibson interviews Nick Smith

Video

Dr Smith said he was "a fan" of Fish and Game and said he had recently approved an increase in its licensing fees. He said his advice that the council "needed to be pro-water quality and not be seen as anti-farming" was honest opinion, not political interference.

He confirmed he wanted changes to the organisation, but said these were related to improvements to the way people could pay their fishing and hunting licensing fees and not to the council's work on freshwater quality.

Notes taken by a Department of Conservation official and released by Dr Smith's office show that the minister questioned Fish and Game's advocacy work.

The notes said: "Big issue - F&G need to work out what they want to be: a statutory body - legislation and a relationship with Government or an NGO?? Statutory monopoly!!"

Fish and Game is a public entity set up under conservation legislation. It receives no taxpayer money and operates independently.

Read more:
*Nick Smith's legal threat over bullying claim

Dr Smith was criticised by Labour, Greens, and National's coalition partner United Future, who defended Fish and Game's work.

Fish and Game Council
*Public entity established in 1987 by Conservation Act.
*Statutory obligations include development of policy to manage sports fishing and hunting resources, and advocacy work.
*Funded by a fee paid on hunting and freshwater fishing licences, and receives no central or local government money.

- NZ Herald

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 18 Dec 2014 17:38:04 Processing Time: 538ms