WCS led for most of the game, but back-to-back non-kickable penalties after the fulltime whistle cost the home side dearly.
WCS director of rugby Guy Lennox said the home side had led 10-5 for the majority of the game and well into the second half when Lindisfarne scored to take the lead.
"We scored again and it was 17-12 coming up to full time. We got a penalty close to time, but didn't kick it out," Lennox said.
"Then they received back-to-back non-kickable penalties that kept the game rolling well after full time. Unfortunately, that ended with a try to Lindisfarne and a final score of 19-17.
"We had our chances and just didn't take them."
Injury has plagued the WCS 1st XV for most of the season and yesterday at least four or five key players were missing.
First-five and sometimes fullback Cody Hemi is still recovering from a broken jaw received when playing for Steelform Wanganui in the Ranfurly Shield warm-up game against Manawatu Evergreens, while centre Opetini Dryden, second-five Zac Simpson and flanker Angus Taylor were also missing. Rising loose forward star Toby Lennox is also out with a shoulder injury that could require surgery.
Meanwhile, it was the exact opposite for the the Under-15 rugby XV and the colts boys hockey with at least four players pulling double duty yesterday.
The WCS 1st Xv rugby team was sitting sixth in the CNI premiership before yesterday's game, but apart of competition leaders St Peter's College and WCS the other side have played at least one game less.