Before the challenge got under way, Fisher and Lloyd-Forrest looked over the food selection with some trepidation.
"I'm a bit worried about the cooking challenge.
"I'm really not a good cook. I better not tell the ladies that," said Fisher.
Despite winning, they did face a few bumps along the way. Lloyd-Forrest had some frosting drama.
At first the frosting was too stiff, but after heating it up the frosting became too runny and sent her cake on a slope. It became the leaning tower of cake.
To her surprise, McGregor said it actually worked in her favour after he tasted the cake.
He said it had made the cake perfectly moist.
Taking the win was a massive shock to them both, especially Fisher who jumped for joy.
"I'm in absolute shock — cooking is not my thing at all," he said.