"The only redeeming factor is that whanau of the four [alleged] offenders located the boys, got the full story from them and have put them forward to be held accountable for their actions."
She praised the actions of the boys' families, who delivered them to her doorstep at the station in Pukenui before she even knew the burglaries had taken place. She hoped the example they had set would deter others from committing burglaries in future.
She interviewed three of the alleged offenders on Monday, and was due to see the fourth on Tuesday.
"They have been forthcoming to me, however this in no way makes amends for their actions. They will have to answer to their community for that," she said.
Almost all the stolen property had been recovered, and she expected to retrieve the last few outstanding items.
Ms Knowler was planning to let the families decide how the boys should atone, with the option of laying formal charges as a last resort.
"That's something Bonnie would've wanted," she said.
Mrs Conrad had a huge personality, and calling into the store would not be same without hearing her voice somewhere in the background.
"She helped many people over the years, locals and travellers, and most went home with their stories of the legendary ice creams," she added.