The taxi driver took her back to the bar where she could call another cab small enough to take her up her driveway. As he got out of the cab at the bar, Harding punched him in the mouth. The blow cracked his partial plate. In his victim impact statement, the taxi driver said he had to stop work and wash blood from his face after the assault.
"I was angry and upset that this woman would do this to me," he said.
Harding's lawyer Wiremu Puriri said all manner of vehicles had gone up her driveway in the past but the taxi driver refused.
Mr Cafferkey said there was nothing in the New Zealand transport law that required taxi drivers to drop off passengers at their doorsteps.
In cases where passengers were disabled or blind and had to be dropped off in areas where cabs could not access, he said taxi drivers usually assisted them to their destination.
"We can't position taxis where they can't turn. It's no different to a removal truck which can't turn up a driveway."
Mr Cafferkey said Mr Murphy was obviously quite traumatised because he did not expect a punch from a woman of that age.
Harding and three other homeowners who share the driveway forked out $10,000 a couple of years ago to have the driveway sealed, she said.
When approached at home she said the taxi driver simply did not want to come up as he did not like the driveway.