She was reluctant to say who was behind the gift.
Police were called and worked with the Department of Conservation to carry out a handover of the tortoise in Kaitāia’s main street.
The tortoise then made the almost-300km journey home where Sergeant Dan McDermott said he had settled back into the park - his home since his early years.
“He is a bit shell-shocked, but appears to be settling back in well.”
Police said sadly, the iguana was still missing.
“We are growing more concerned about the welfare of the iguana and want to see her returned to the park,” McDermott said.
“An iguana is not a suitable pet for someone who doesn’t understand what care is required, and we are imploring anyone with information to please get in touch.”
Police were continuing to investigate the theft of the tortoise, including how it travelled to Kaitāia.
“We are working together with our colleagues in Northland to identify the suspects and hold them to account,” McDermott said.
Ti Point Reptile Park manager Mike Chillingworth told Stuff the animals required specific care and were not suitable as pets.
In 2010, 16 green geckos were also stolen from the Ti Point Reptile Park.
Anyone with footage or information that may assist police is asked to contact them via 105 or online at www.police.govt.nz/use-105, using Update My Report. Reference file number 240320/8108. Information can also be provided anonymously via Crime Stoppers on 0800 555 111.