"We had to make a decision whether to defend or attack, but we decided to carry on playing and keep seeing if we could get more opportunities."
McCabe said the second half was a much more even affair with Onerahi's midfield combining nicely to score a goal about 15 minutes into the half. With Onerahi pushing more players forward, Kerikeri had to fall back and use all their defensive skills to hold onto the 2-1 scoreline.
In the previous fixture between the two teams, Onerahi came out on top with a 4-1 win. McCabe said he was confident of getting a good result from Sunday's game if his side reduced their errors.
"When we played last time, we were the ones making mistakes and [Onerahi] capitalised," McCabe said.
"Looking at the way we've been training in the last few weeks, I didn't see how we couldn't get a few goals against them."
Even with a game in hand, Kerikeri need Onerahi to draw one of their three remaining games as well as winning their own games to have a shot at the title.
In the round's other games, Tikipunga beat Kaitaia, 7-1, and Bream Bay beat Kamo, 3-0. The Northland FC women's team lost 2-0 to Ellerslie on Sunday at Tikipunga Sports Park.