PCP says seven cats remain. The council believes the number is lower. The group has collected more than 700 signatures calling on the council to allow the cats to stay.
Saturday's protestors carried banners with messages such as "BBA go away" and "Save our pets from fanatics". Some wore cat ears or cat face paint, and chants alternated with meowing.
Former national SPCA chief executive Jim Boyd, now living at Okaihau, was among the speakers. He said removing cats from an area with a large number of restaurants would lead to an increase in rats and mice, which would have a more detrimental effect on wildlife than the colony's cats.
Les Robinson, of Kerikeri, said the youngest cat was about 10 so they posed no threat to wildlife. She dismissed the council's plans to re-home the cats, saying they were used to being free and would suffer "acute separation anxiety" if removed from the people who had fed them for many years.
Mr Kurz said Saturday morning's heavy rain had affected the turnout but the group had shown it could mount a protest. The next one would be bigger, he said. PCP was also taking steps to become an incorporated society.
Mrs Chapman said she wanted the feeding station returned before winter set in, as demanded by the 700-plus people who had signed the petition.
"The sooner we get it back the better. It's just so cruel."
She was pleased with the turnout given the weather.