Jess Macalister opened the scoring for Old Girls in the second quarter of the match but the lead was short-lived as Aimee-Leigh Scott levelled the score off the back of a quick breakout soon afterwards.
Most of the play was end-to-end, with both goalkeepers forced to make crucial saves. In the final quarter Girls' High took the lead from a well-worked penalty corner variation.
Old Girls' then piled on the pressure, and after a sustained attack were able to score off a penalty corner in the final minute to end the game in a 2-all draw.
Moscrip commented after the match, "We need to learn from that ... we need to experience the fails so we know how to win."
In other women's matches on Saturday, Springfield beat Maungakaramea 4-1 and Hikurangi outclassed Mangapai 3-0.
In the premier men's competition, Mangapai took down Maungakaramea 2-1 on Friday night and Springfield beat Bream Bay 3-1 on Saturday.