At that point, the results were yet to be published, and Denyer was not sure of the exact number of votes, but said he was pleased to be the new mayor and was "looking forward to it".
A couple of hours later, Denyer later told the Bay of Plenty Times he originally thought the contention for the mayoralty would be close, so he was surprised to win by such a margin.
"I wouldn't have stood if I didn't think I wouldn't have a good chance. I was quietly confident but it was a tough field. There were a lot of interesting things at play."
Denyer described rival mayoral hopeful John Scrimgeour as a "strong candidate" who was up against fellow mayoral contender Mark Boyle for the Te Puke vote, who was also strong competition, he said.
"And of course, you have Don Thwaites who is a strong contender as well, and then Rodney [Joyce] from Katikati so you could say he took some of my home votes.
"It's great to have ... people believe in me," Denyer said.
Denyer will replace Garry Webber, who has retired after several years on the council, including two terms as mayor.
In announcing his candidacy, Denyer, 46, said there were four main issues he would like to tackle.
One was future-planning locally and getting the review of the district plan right in a ''rapidly changing'' resource management framework.
He also wanted to improve infrastructure and community facilities.
'"In Katikati, we need an upgraded town centre with roundabouts to bookend the town and improve access, footpath improvements and construction of a market square."
James advocated for the Katikati bypass and was on the stakeholder reference group working with NZTA.
"I will continue to advocate for the bypass, but recognise that it will likely be a political decision.
'"In Ōmokoroa, I want to get the SH2 intersection over the line and built, and advocate for stage two of the Takitimu North Link to be built as soon as possible. I also feel it is important to retain green spaces on the peninsula as the housing is intensified.
"At Waihi Beach, I want to see some longstanding projects like the Athenree crossing and an upgraded library get under way.
Rival mayoral candidate Don Thwaites admitted he was disappointed he was not successful, but commended Denyer's "outstanding effort" and said Denyer's new role was "well earned".
"He's worked so hard for the last three years. He's attended every community meeting and he has been tireless in his campaign; he's forever working hard and learning."
In the lead-up to this year's local body elections, the Western Bay of Plenty District Council had been proactively encouraging people to consider standing in the elections and to vote. The council has done much of this campaigning via a website and project called Generation Change.
"It really is a generational change," Thwaites said.
Candidates who put their names forward for the mayoralty were Suaree Borell, Boyle, Denyer, Paul Haimona, Rodney Joyce, Terry "Hori BOP" Leaming, Scrimgeour and Thwaites.
Western Bay of Plenty District Council is made up of one mayor and 11 councillors.
The councillors are elected from three wards - Kaimai (four councillors), Katikati/Waihi Beach (three councillors), and Maketu-Te Puke (four councillors). There are also five community boards, each with four members.
Council candidates currently elected are:
James Denyer: Mayor
Anne Henry: Katikati-Waihī Beach
Rodney Joyce: Katikati-Waihī Beach
Allan Sole: Katikati-Waihī Beach
Tracey Coxhead: Kaimai
Murray Grainger: Kaimai
Margaret Murray-Benge: Kaimai
Don Thwaites: Kaimai
Richard Crawford: Maketu-Te Puke
Grant Dally: Maketu-Te Puke
John Scrimgeour: Maketu-Te Puke
Andy Wichers: Maketu-Te Puke
In total, 59 candidates contested the 32 seats comprising a mayor, councillors and community board members.
Preliminary results are expected to be available on Sunday. Official and final results will be available by Friday, October 14 and posted on generationchange.nz and the council's website.
