Taiwan is banning eating cats and dogs, but many of its neighbours haven't

By Kristine Phillips

A Taiwanese man holds his dog during a gathering to demand establishment of a government department to protect dogs and cats. Photo / AP file
A Taiwanese man holds his dog during a gathering to demand establishment of a government department to protect dogs and cats. Photo / AP file

Taiwan has banned the sale and consumption of cat and dog meat, a departure from a controversial practice that is common among its Asian neighbours.

The island's legislature amended the Animal Protection Act, imposing steeper fines and lengthier punishments for acts related to animal cruelty.

These include a fine of about US$1600 to US$8000 for anyone caught selling or consuming cat and dog meat, or any other products that contain parts of the animals, according to Taiwan's Central News Agency. The Government will publicise the names and pictures of offenders.

Animal-cruelty acts are now punishable by up to two years in prison and a fine of about US$6500 to US$65,400, according to the Central News Agency. Previously, the maximum punishment was one year in prison and up to US$32,700 in fines.

The amendments to the Animal Protection Act, enacted in 1998, come at a time of heightened awareness about animal cruelty in the country. Taiwan's President, Tsai Ing Wen, adopted three retired guide dogs in October, the Central News Agency reported. She also has two cats.

Canine meat, however, is still widely consumed in many Asian countries, specifically China, South Korea, Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, the Philippines and northern India, according to Humane Society International. The practice also exists in parts of Africa and remote areas of Switzerland.

Perhaps the most controversial is China's dog-eating festival in the town of Yulin, where thousands of canines are slaughtered annually. The event has been bombarded with petitions and online campaigns in recent years.

In 2016, Chinese and international animal rights activists presented a petition with 11 million signatures to protest against the dog-meat festival. They say many of the dogs were either stolen or found astray, crammed in small cages and beaten to death in slaughterhouses.

China is thought to have killed more than 10 million of the roughly 30 million dogs slaughtered every year worldwide, according to Humane Society International. Four million cats are killed every year in the country.

In South Korea, where dogs are farmed for human consumption, about two million are kept in about 17,000 facilities, and many are killed by electrocution, according to the organisation. The country's law on the legality of the dog-meat trade remains ambiguous, according to the Animal Welfare Institute, and government efforts to put an end to it have been halfhearted.

Consuming dogs, however, has become increasingly controversial and frowned upon in Asia.

A growing number of Chinese, particularly in middle-class and urban areas, lean more towards owning the animals as pets.

More than 800 dogs also have been rescued from animal farms in South Korea, according to Humane Society International. The animals have been flown to shelters in the United States. Seven dog-meat farms have been shut down.

Humane Society International said it has provided money and counselling to farmers who have gotten out of the dog-meat industry.

In 2013, Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand and Laos struck a deal to stop the trafficking of dogs for their meat, according to Time magazine.

In the Philippines, Agriculture Secretary Proceso Alcala has called for the eradication of the country's thriving dog-meat industry. Alcala signed a directive in January 2016 outlining a campaign to end dog-meat trade by 2020. Part of the plan is to increase public awareness about the health hazards of eating canine meat and focus the government crackdown on areas where the practice remains rampant.


Killing and selling dogs for meat has been banned in the capital, Manila, for more than 30 years. A nationwide ban was enacted in 1998. The Anti-Rabies Act, passed in 2007, imposes more penalties and punishments for trading dogs for meat. But Alcala acknowledged that officials have fallen short in enforcing those laws.

"While the public may be aware of the prohibition on the trade of dogs for their meat and the underlying and accompanying atrocity involved in the treatment and handling of dogs, the magnitude of effects on the menace of eating of dog meat considering its health hazards has been downplayed, if not ignored," according to the directive.

In a statement praising the Taiwanese legislature's recent action, Humane Society International said the changes to the law should send a message to mainland China and other countries where consuming dog meat remains legal.

"Taiwan's legislature has taken a monumental step in ending the dog-meat trade," the organisation said. "Most people in Asian countries do not eat dog and cat, and most find the cruel and often crime-fuelled trade appalling."

The practice is limited but does exist in the United States, according to Humane Society International. But legislation introduced last month, the Dog and Cat Meat Trade Prohibition Act, would ban the killing and selling of cats and dogs for human consumption in the country.

- Washington Post

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter

SIGN UP NOW

© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf05 at 23 May 2017 19:13:04 Processing Time: 448ms