Stop saying 'This isn't my America.' Sorry, it is.

By Monica Hesse

Cheers for Donald Trump inside an election-night event in New York City. Photo / The Washington Post
Cheers for Donald Trump inside an election-night event in New York City. Photo / The Washington Post

COMMENT

So this is America, after all.

It's not the one many of us hoped we lived in right now, but it's the one verified by the electoral map, and it's the one that others of us have feared we lived in for a very long time.

All through the election, Hillary Clinton's surrogates tried to repudiate the possibility of a Donald Trump presidency and all of its strident, fear-laden rhetoric.

America is better than that, they said. Those values aren't American; those values don't represent us.

All through yesterday, Wolf Blitzer and John King bickered in front of their CNN Magic Wall about the "surprise" and "upset" of Trump's victory. No one saw it coming, they said. Nobody could explain it.

It wasn't until later that Van Jones, an African-American political commenter, broke in with a shaking, emotional voice and offered his explanation: "This was a white-lash," he said.

"This was a white-lash against a changing country. It was a white-lash against a black president, in part. And that's the part where the pain comes."

What if America isn't better than that? What if this was America all along?

Not the America that welcomed immigrant "huddled masses," but the America that kidnapped African slaves and made them build a country, brick by brick and cotton field by cotton field.

Not the America that lets women work and dress and worship as they please, but the America in which a man who sexually assaults one of them can be imprisoned for only three months. Not the America pulled along by hope but the America pushed along by aggression.

The people who were truly shocked by the outcome are those who have never experienced certain behaviours of the citizenry.

Good men don't realise that when women are walking alone, every single block can feel like a gauntlet of harassment. It's no wonder they don't realise this - bad men make sure to treat women politely when women are accompanied by male friends.

Good white people don't fully understand why people of colour fear encounters with the police, because the police have been mostly kind to them.

"I'm seeing so many posts, from mostly white friends, saying, 'America, I don't even know you,' " says Wendy Tien, a Milwaukee lawyer and second-generation Taiwanese American.

"And I'm thinking, 'Where have you been? What do you mean you don't know this America? Why haven't you seen it?' I've seen it. I see it all the time."

On Twitter, after news organisations predicted the Republican candidate's win, a woman wrote, "America: We knew this was in us. We usually like to pretend it's a mistake or something we can ignore or mock. We can't do that anymore."

Analysts have been poring over the numbers, announcing that this was not really an election about race, but about class.

There were, after all, counties that voted for Barack Obama in 2012 and this year voted for Donald Trump.

This was not really an election about gender, but about one particular woman that many people, including in her own party, hated.

This was not really an election about xenophobia, they said, but an election about free-trade agreements and jobs.

This might all be true.

Nobody can look inside the hearts of voters and determine with certainty what makes one candidate viscerally more appealing than another.

Could this election, for some voters, have been a culmination of many factors? Economics, race, geography and gender? America's history has never been a simple narrative.

If this election taught us anything, it's that we haven't all been living in the country in the same way.

"Now do you believe us?" tweeted Xeni Jardin, an editor in California. "Us girls and women? Now do you believe Americans who are not white when they say white supremacy prevails?"

Jardin, who is white, grew up in a Southern city across from a prison, where she remembers that mostly white spectators would gather with coolers to celebrate the executions of mostly black inmates.

But, she says, polite people didn't discuss such things, just like they didn't discuss sexual violence or other mistreatment of women.

It just existed, quietly, part of the rotten underbelly of that America.

Now it exists, loudly, part of the blaring horn of this one.


- Washington Post

Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter

SIGN UP NOW

© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf05 at 02 Mar 2017 06:57:38 Processing Time: 615ms