Instead, NASCAR took the unprecedented step of adding Jeff Gordon as a 13th driver to the field and placed Penske and Front Row on probation for the remainder of the season.
Logano never thought he'd be kicked out of the Chase despite the vitriol he was seeing on social media.
"There wasn't any worry in my mind that we weren't going to be in the Chase. I felt like we deserved to be here," Logano said. "I realize there are a lot of people on Twitter that are really mean. I've read enough of it, and I thought, 'Wow, this Joey Logano guy's a real jerk.' Then I realized, 'You know, maybe I'm not.'
"Hopefully this helps prove them all wrong, that we deserve to be here, because this team has got what it takes and we've proven that all year long. I guess we have to do that for 10 more races and prove them wrong a little bit more."
The Chase begins Sunday at Chicagoland Speedway, where NASCAR will have a 13-driver championship field for the first time since the title-deciding format began in 2004.
Juan Pablo Montoya, who qualified third, made light of the controversy.
"The question I asked when coming in here is maybe qualifying third I could make the Chase, too," he said.
Chase driver Kasey Kahne was fourth and followed by Ricky Stenhouse Jr.
Next was Gordon, who had an emotional week watching the fallout from Richmond unfold. He thought he missed the Chase on performance, then learned the spin last weekend with seven laps to go by Clint Bowyer was a deliberate attempt to manipulate the outcome for Truex's benefit.
Things just got worse from there as Gordon learned of another plot by MWR's drivers to help Logano push Gordon out of the Chase, and then of the Penske and Front Row potential bargaining. He came to Chicago aware NASCAR was still reviewing the situation but not hopeful it would change his situation.
He learned he'd been added to the field watching NASCAR chairman Brian France make the announcement on television before qualifying.
"It was hard to not hear rumblings about what may occur, what may not occur. We just tried not to get our hopes up," he said. "I'm very thankful to be in, and I know it's under the most unbelievable circumstances I've ever been a part of in my racing career, and I wish that all of this hadn't happened. Now here we are as a 13th car and in, now we just try to take that opportunity and make the most of it."
Chase drivers made up the next four spots as Greg Biffle was seventh and followed by Carl Edwards, Jimmie Johnson and points leader Matt Kenseth.
Bowyer was the lowest qualifying Chase driver at 24th.