Sideline Champs: Referee mum sure she was targeted

By Susan Edmunds

Wish to win and ignorance about the rules could be behind sideline heckling

Tina Karreman says the abuse from players and parents was phenomenal. "They think females have no idea about sport," she says. Photo / Supplied
Tina Karreman says the abuse from players and parents was phenomenal. "They think females have no idea about sport," she says. Photo / Supplied

Tina Karreman knew it was time to give up coaching and refereeing soccer games when her sons, then 14 and 17, told her how much it upset them to see her abused.

She was a capable ref - shoulder-tapped to represent New Zealand in international games. But being in the centre of a kids' football game, she copped so much abuse that she could not see a future with the whistle.

"My son said, 'Every time you finish refereeing, you're bawling your eyes out'."

The Christchurch mum had been involved in the game for seven years. She spoke out as part of the Herald on Sunday's Sideline Champs campaign, which started last week, to improve sport crowd behaviour.

Three years on, she is sure she was targeted for abuse because she is a woman.

"You get abused by players, parents, everyone. They think females have no idea about sport, especially a male-dominated sport."

Some of the abuse was physically threatening. It wore her down to the point where she couldn't face it.

"There's no respect for anyone in the centre but it's most definitely a lot worse for female referees. I would have liked to have carried on but it's just not worth it."

Showing angry parents the rule book and explaining her decisions did nothing to placate them.

"It's just atrocious, I don't know how people cope."

Ms Karreman says she can't see a way to change the behaviour. Some of it is a lack of understanding of the rules and a well-meaning desire to see kids succeed.

But she says that passion goes overboard and it takes only one or two people to turn sideline support into nasty heckling. "There is passion but there is no need for the verbal diarrhoea that goes with it."

Even players seemed to buy into the attitude that women were ineffective coaches. "A new player was told when registering that he would be in my team of players from last year. The look of disgust and the attitude he showed me was unbelievable unless you saw it."

Ms Karreman is now vice-president of the football club, running administration. "Even now, I still get it. There are men walking around thinking, 'Who the frig are you?' When the grounds are closed and I walk up and say, 'Excuse me, you can't be here', I get the attitude of, 'What right have you to tell me what to do?"'

Meanwhile, an academic says New Zealanders need to take steps to improve sideline behaviour. Professor Sarah Leberman, who heads Massey University's School of Management, specialises in women in sports management.

She has done work in the US and New Zealand looking at why relatively few women are involved in coaching kids' sports teams. She has found it is due to the verbal abuse and lack of respect they get from other parents.

She said many women reported that they could put up with heckling and verbal attacks for a while but when it happened week after week, it became too much to handle. Professor Leberman said sports organisations hoped the problem would ease, but it seemed to be getting worse.

"There's no mechanism to control it because the referee or umpire is just trying to keep what's happening on court happening; they can't deal with the parents, too."

US colleagues had developed a package to help parents and coaches combat bad sideline behaviour.

Efforts to counter it needed to come from within sport, she said. "We've been quite reactive, we haven't taken the initiative, we should do something more constructive."

- Herald on Sunday

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf01 at 28 Dec 2014 21:58:31 Processing Time: 519ms