View interactive

Judges' work under lens

By Lynley Bilby

Plan to build public trust in district courts

Jan-Marie Doogue. Photo / Duncan Brown
Jan-Marie Doogue. Photo / Duncan Brown

The chief judge of the District Court is finalising a proposal to subject New Zealand's 133 district court judges to performance reviews and greater public scrutiny.

A discussion paper released at yesterday's Asia Pacific Courts Conference outlined a plan for the judges to be rated on their performances.

The plan stops short of releasing information on individual judges. Instead, it proposes the public be given a "tempered" version - keeping names secret and focusing on administrative matters. This is intended to preserve the judges' independence and impartiality.

However, the report authors still hoped this would go a long way to bolster public trust and confidence in the nation's courtrooms.

Chief District Court Judge Jan-Marie Doogue said the peer reviews wouldn't assess decisions of individual judges. "This is a health check on the district courts,"she said.

Ten areas of courtroom operation would go under the microscope. They included the time it takes judges to make judgments, giving reasons for decisions, workloads, rostering decisions, public communication and complaints.

Some of the changes are the result of mounting concern from the public and lawyers.

The report cited the high-profile murder of Auckland teenager Christie Marceau and the publicity generated after it was revealed her killer, Akshay Chand, was out on bail when he killed her.

The discussion paper suggested the public should know the reasons for judges' decisions.

"It is imperative that the judiciary therefore takes initiatives to put information about their decisions, both judicial and administrative, into the public arena," it said.

There was also a lack of confidence over judges taking too much time to make reserved decisions.

Sensible Sentencing Trust spokesman Garth McVicor said he wasn't surprised at the move as the judiciary was under increasing pressure to be transparent. He hoped this would bring a mood of openness to the judiciary and praised Doogue for the initiative.

Doogue said there was widespread backing for the review from within the judiciary. The Ministry of Justice would be approached to fund the next stage, she said.

- Herald on Sunday

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a4 at 22 Sep 2014 10:45:47 Processing Time: 544ms